In short: Fantastic Beasts is tons of fun in its own way, but don't go in expecting Harry Potter.
Let me start by saying that I was super excited because I've never seen an HP movie in the theaters (I didn't read the books until a couple years ago, so all the movies had been long out), but I also wasn't sure what to expect since I actually have a copy of the Fantastic Beasts book, and upon flipping through it, I wasn't sure what sort of story they could put together from what is essentially a textbook about magical creatures. What I had gathered from the various Pottermore essays and such in the last year or so was that it would involve Newt Scamander, author of the textbook (so it would take place long before Harry Potter was born), and it would involve wizards in America. (I got sorted as a Thunderbird among Ilvermorny's houses, how about you?)
|This is what I have!|
So first of all, this is not a Harry Potter movie. Yes, it's the same universe, but what I really mean is that it's a different style of film. HP movies are centered around kids/teens, and as such, it has a innocent quality to it, even in the later movies when things get serious. They're primarily about young people and their "young people world."
Fantastic Beasts (which I'll now abbreviate as FB) is a movie about grownups in a grownup world, and you can't get around it. It takes place in New York in the 1920s, and has all the slick style and glitz that you would expect, from the costumes and hair, to the mannerisms, to cinematography. The main characters aren't adolescents trying to figure out their way in the world - they're cosmopolitan adults in the greatest city in the world (to quote Hamilton). The childlike whimsy and cuteness is replaced by speakeasies and jazz music.
Second of all, because it takes place in America, a lot of things are different, and it's going to feel weird, because the wizarding world has always been British to us. It felt weird to see things in an American context. It felt weird to see magic juxtaposed with a specific period in American history - it felt less like fantasy and more like something real, especially given the importance of the Salem witch trials in American history. (Even though we're generally aware that HP takes place in a relatively modern time period, it still has a sort of timeless feel to it.)
Speaking of "real": thirdly, it takes place in the heart of muggle (sorry, No-Maj) city life. HP spends a relatively little amount of time out in the "real world" with muggles - for the most part, we're at Hogwarts, which is isolated from everything muggle, or we're in wizarding towns (like Hogsmeade) or other locations that are secluded (like in Deathly Hallows when the trio are on the run). As such, in FB, we're dealing with the consequences and damage that occur when magic is not practiced in isolation.
So... it's not going to feel like the HP-verse that you know.
But that's okay!
Once I got past the uneasiness I was feeling about this movie NOT being my Harry Potter, it started to grow on me. (My daughter never got over it though - she kept asking when Hermione would show up.) I liked the sophistication and polish. I liked the jazz. I liked the darkness of certain aspects of America's historical past that show up in the form of an anti-witch evangelist and her adopted children. (I don't know, you tell me - didn't she seem somehow uniquely American? Even though I'm sure people like her exist everywhere. IDK.)
And I liked the magical creatures! They were interesting and fascinating, and I could appreciate why Newt Scamander cared about them so much. They were at times cute and at times a little scary, but definitely epic.
There were a LOT of actors that I recognized that I didn't know were in the movie (although, it's not like I spent any time reading up on the cast), and in particular, I want to highlight Ezra Miller's performance. I've only seen him in one other thing (The Perks of Being a Wallflower), and he was amazing in that too.
Is it worth seeing if you're not already into the HP-verse? I don't recall much time being spent on world-building and explanation, as if they are expecting only HP fans to see the movie (not an unreasonable expectation). You don't get a whole lot of explanation about how magic in general works, or about what the spells are or anything (like, I guess you could figure out by inference that alohomora opens locked doors?), and I would've liked to know more about the MACUSA and how the American magic laws work (though maybe I could just hit up Pottermore for that explanation). So if this is your first foray into the HP-verse, it might be a bumpy ride but enjoyable nonetheless. Edited to add: Entertainment Weekly just posted this great list of 5 things to know before watching the movie.
Is it worth seeing if you're already a diehard HP fan? Yes. But like I said, it's going to feel a little weird to you, but keep an open mind and you'll be fine :) Fantastic Beasts was super fun, and I walked out of the theater more excited than I'd walked in.